Set up a peer assessment
Overview
You set up a peer assessment the same way you create any assignment, then work through the peer-specific panels. The setup is grouped into sections you can move between as you configure the cycle: The assignment, The assessment, Pods & assessors, and Reflection & gallery.
The assignment
This section describes what students submit and which objectives their work is assessed against.
- What students submit — the submission format for the authored work, including whether to Allow Group Work.
- Objectives mode — how the assessment objectives are chosen. TeachFront supports three sources of objectives, and you can combine them:
- Objectives every assessor assesses against — course objectives you select. Set a Minimum course objectives per assessor.
- Student-invented objectives — criteria students propose themselves. Set a Minimum student-invented objectives per assessor, and optionally Require a rubric and Require specifications for those criteria.
- A Total objectives per assessor ceiling across the sets.
- Edit objectives, rubrics, & specs — open the objective editor to write each objective, its rubric, and its specifications.
The assessment
This section controls how assessors mark the work.
- Review type — choose Calibrated CPR review or Peer review. Calibrated review adds the calibration exercise students complete before their queue unlocks.
- Calibration Exercise for This Cycle — record whether students calibrate before assessing. This setting decides whether a Calibration step appears on the student landing page at all: with it off, students see no Calibration step. With it on, the Marked Examples you add on the Marked Examples panel decide whether that step can run — an Example for Calibration is kept out of the assessing queue, and students must finish calibrating on those of them placed on every objective the cycle shares before their graded queue opens. See Place your Marked Examples.
- Instructions to assessors — guidance shown to students as they assess.
- Anonymous mode for this cycle — hide author and assessor identities within the pod.
Place your Marked Examples
A Marked Example is a piece of work the teaching team authors for the cycle. Each one is either an Example for Marking — students assess it in their assessing queue, scored against your mark — or an Example for Calibration — students practise on it and see the gap to your mark. You add both kinds on the Marked Examples panel with Add a Marked Example.
Your placements on a Marked Example are the standard students calibrate against. Placing an example against an objective is what creates the reference for that objective — rating the example the way you would rate a student submission is a separate action and does not stand in for a placement.
Two rules follow from that, and both are worth knowing before you publish the cycle:
- A Marked Example joins the calibration set only when it is placed on every objective the cycle shares. A partly placed example is not served to students, so they never meet a calibration screen with blank criteria on it.
- Sharing a new objective to the cycle takes an already-placed Marked Example back out of the set until you place that example on the new objective too. Adding an objective is the common way a calibration exercise quietly loses its examples, so re-open your Marked Examples after any objective change and place the ones you want back in.
If a cycle ends up with no fully placed Example for Calibration — whether because none was added or because the ones added are not placed on every shared objective — there is nothing to calibrate against and students go straight to assessing. The Calibration step still appears on their landing page, because you recorded calibration for this cycle, but it reads Unavailable for this cycle and does nothing — it is not reported as finished, and it does not hold their queue shut. That wording names no cause on purpose, because a student cannot act on any of the causes, so the fix is yours: add an Example for Calibration, or place the ones you have on every shared objective. If you did not want calibration on this cycle at all, turn Calibration Exercise for This Cycle off and the step disappears instead.
Pods & assessors
This section sets who assesses whom and the assess-the-assessor grade.
- Assessor assignment objectives — choose whether assessors are graded against the Same set as this assignment or A different set of objectives.
- Assess-the-assessor — turn on Create an assess-the-assessor assignment to add the second gradebook entry for assessing quality. When enabled you can set the Autograde aggregation method — for example, Autograde by distance from the pod median.
- Ratings due — the deadline for assessors to commit their ratings.
- Reassessment requests — Allow reassessment requests lets authors ask for a second look at a mark. See Monitor a peer assessment and share results.
Reflection & gallery
This section controls what happens after the marks are in.
- Enable gallery discussion — open the pod gallery so members can discuss each other's assessments. Add Gallery discussion prompts, one per line and Custom instructions to students for the gallery.
- Discussion objective — optionally grade discussion participation against an objective, with a Minimum discussion replies, Minimum unique discussion threads, Minimum discussion word count, and a Discussion due date.
- Let assessors revise their marks after discussion — allow students to update their marks once the discussion has happened.
- Release feedback to authors — control when authors can read the feedback their pod wrote about their work.
Related
Troubleshooting
| Situation | What to try |
|---|---|
| Students cannot start assessing | On Calibrated CPR review, students must finish calibration first. Confirm each Example for Calibration carries your placement on every criterion. Students are only ever held back by Marked Examples they are actually shown — an example you have not finished placing is not part of the calibration set and does not hold their queue shut. |
| A Marked Example disappeared from the calibration exercise | The example is placed on some, but not all, of the cycle's shared objectives — most often because an objective was added to the cycle after you placed it. Place the example on the remaining objectives to bring it back. See Place your Marked Examples. |
| Students report the Calibration step reads Unavailable for this cycle | You recorded calibration for this cycle, so the step is shown, but the cycle has no usable Example for Calibration, so there is nothing to calibrate against. Two different situations produce this, and they have different fixes. Either the cycle has no Example for Calibration at all — every example on it is an Example for Marking, which never joins the calibration set however fully it is placed, because students are graded on it — in which case add one, or designate an existing example as Example for Calibration. Or one exists and is not placed on every objective the cycle shares, in which case place it on the remaining objectives. If you did not want calibration here at all, turn Calibration Exercise for This Cycle off, which removes the step. While calibration is unavailable students are not blocked and assess as normal; once any of these changes makes it available, they must complete it before their assessing queue opens. |
| Students report Not rated on a Marked Example you have placed | Confirm you are looking at the same cycle, and that your placements were saved on the Marked Example rather than entered as ordinary ratings on it. The reveal shows your placement for each objective. |
| No assess-the-assessor grade in the gradebook | Confirm Create an assess-the-assessor assignment is enabled in Pods & assessors. |
| Gallery discussion not visible to students | Confirm Enable gallery discussion is on and feedback release settings allow it. |